lichess.org
Donate

Should Chess Have Affirmitive Action? Shouldn't we do more to combat racism in chess?

I'm in favor of these measures. What do I get for my 2.8% Neanderthal DNA? And for my 4.2 % Denisovan DNA?
It's cumulative, right?
Its best not to reply to this kind of degenerate. The difference between sports and life is that in sports everyone starts with equal opportunities, in life the state has to help out. To claim that black people are inferior because they don't do so well in chess, is as stupid as claiming that Russians are the master race.
@msck "Equal outcomes? What would that be in chess? Do you just give every minority player 200 higher ELO for free? That would be ridiculously racist."

What's wrong with making it like med school, where we just after-the-fact change the outcome? Giving 200 ELO is exactly like giving virtual MCAT points to applicants based on race. Why do you need to resort to ad hominen attacks? I'm trying to help. We're all equal in every single way, so let's force it to be that way like the US government does. Don't you think Whites and Blacks should have surgery done on their legs so we're the same height as Asians? It's only fair and part of being a good liberal.

Also, by calling me a troll I think you assumed my gender. That's extremely sexist. You should go to time out and think about what you've done.
When someone can say nothing other than name calling, you know you're right.

Respond with logic. I hope most people are good enough to see through childish name calling.
I thought all the racist old white men were assuaged now that Trump won..
More insults. No facts. No substance. Asking for equality is criminalized. Facts are criminalized. Truly an Orwellian future we're in with political correctness in the world today. Anything you disagree with: just call them a racist. Even if I'm a young minority. I *must* be a racist old white man. How stupid are people?
I'm against affirmative actions in general since they do not actually solve any problems. It's inherently unfair to both sides. Those discriminated against by AA of course suffer. However those "aided" by AA suffer as well since they are not required to work as hard as what they could have done if AA does not exist.

In particular I'm against affirmative actions in this case. For example if black players always compete with white and Asian ones with a queen up they will probably not even try to learn how to play with top players when both sides have a queen.

Years of AA. No major improvement observed among ghetto black Americans because AA is inherently against human nature by disrupting the free market. Time to make some changes.
I agree. It's insulting to say "You can get in with only 62%." Everyone is capable of succeeding. We need to address cure the disease, not mask the symptoms. Money could be spent on special programs to provide Black communities opportunities to learn about STEM fields and get involved from a young age.

Putting in "easier hurdles" at the end of the race for certain people dependant on race is actually the most racist thing going on here, and it's racist to everyone involved. Give everyone the same opportunities at the start of the race and let people succeed based on their individual accomplishments.
^This is not just an American issue however it is indeed serious in America. You can refurbish houses in poor black communities forever and feed their inhabitants without their lives actually improving because what they really need is the ability to form successful communities. Without changing the inhabitants the ghettos can never be changed. You can even give them Tokyo and they can still manage to make it Detroit if they do not know how to run a successful city.

I would like to remind people that AA also causes racist feelings. One unintended consequence of AA is that people who "benefit from" it tend to be less competent than others in the same position. Hence it disrupts the education system and industries. At the same time it makes people who work with AA hires really mad because AA hires tend to be less competent and can mess things up easily not because of their race but because of the well-intentioned but stupid AA program.

Aid to Africa needs to largely stop as well. Yes we should feed them and give them medicine and vaccines when necessary. However any unnecessary aid actually harms black Africans in the long run by making their businesses even less competent. For example you can buy a lot of mosquito tents from China and then donate it to a Western charity which gives the tents away for free. One consequence is that you have destroyed some local businesses who are providing similar products. What Africans really need is the same standard as everyone else and a free market. No I don't want to hear about starving Africans forever for mere aid can never stop them from starving. Can they provide something good instead, such as some nice African food that non-Africans can also enjoy? At least they can actually be proud and make some real money providing others products of their own wisdom and efforts.

This topic has been archived and can no longer be replied to.