lichess.org
Donate

New Variant Idea

I love playing the lichess variants, but how about this idea:

Every 5 moves you get to make your opponents move for them

So otherwise the game is normal but for those 1 in 5 moves you can move their queen to a vulnerable square etc
Sounds boring to me, because you could blunder for your opponent(yes he can do this to you too). What about for the first 5 moves you have to give your opponent 3 different moves you like to do (in every turn) and he has to choose one of them. For example first move with white: I suggest to my opponent: e4, d4, knight c3. Then black choose one of my moves and black will continue the same way as white. This will last for the first 5 moves.
@Cedur216 how about you chose what piece your opponent has to move? You could chose the queen but your opponent get to decide where.
@Flightcaptain said in #5:
> Sounds boring to me, because you could blunder for your opponent(yes he can do this to you too). What about for the first 5 moves you have to give your opponent 3 different moves you like to do (in every turn) and he has to choose one of them. For example first move with white: I suggest to my opponent: e4, d4, knight c3. Then black choose one of my moves and black will continue the same way as white. This will last for the first 5 moves.

I do like the idea, but I think it would become a hassle and take so long just to make one move
PSA: you can invent hundreds of "variants" by just a single idea to alter one tiny thing of the game or creating one tiny additional rule, and call it a "variant".

But most of these are way too similar, hence not interesting and all variants end up ignored if there are way too many of them. Lichess does a wise job by having eight very distinct variants and no more. Even then, variants are generally only 10% as popular as standard chess. There's pychess for more sophisticated variants, but it severely lacks influence.
I do not like variants in general. Standard chess is hard enough, there's no need for something else to keep me interested in the game. The only variant I think has a legitimate reason to be taken serious is chess 960 because it solves an actual problem of modern chess. But that problem only exists at the highest echelons. At my level I am perfectly content with just playing old fashioned, centuries old chess.

This topic has been archived and can no longer be replied to.